While most of my posts are filled with tasting notes of various whiskies explored, I must disclose the observations are typically an amalgam of several palates as the drams are shared and discussed as part of whisky clubs.
I value the different reactions to what we try and recognize our perceptions of a whisky’s aroma and taste is inextricably linked to associated memories of distinctive yet familiar smells and flavours.
Hence you will often find my tasting notes peppered with references that are both common to say North America and equally India. This is simply a part of the duality of my life – hailing originally from Canada but living long term in India. Our cultural and culinary context influences our interpretation of a whisky.
For the most part, palate preferences are specific to an individual. Some love deep dark rich sherry drams, others long for the curl of peat, some prefer fruity and others saltier fare… for many, like me, preferences are context and mood dependent. My preferences have also shifted significantly over the years as I’ve gained exposure into different styles and the extraordinary range the world of whisky has to offer.
So why then was I so surprised at our last Whisky Ladies session… Where there was a very clear distinction between the reaction of those whose origins are outside of India vs those whose origins are within?
It was our first and only time where there was such a divide – sure we have different reactions and different opinions. That’s half the fun! But not so diametrically opposed along lines of origins.
And what was the controversial whisky that provoked such a reaction? The Aultmore 5 year 66.8% Master of Malt which was first sampled as part of an exception evening of “Dream Drams” with India’s Malt Maniac Krishna Nakula.
The notes I took did not reflect the full story:
- Nose – Sherry, chocolate, nutty, figs, dates, banana bread with nuts and sultanas
- Palate – For some it was smooth, bursting with rich Christmas cake for others a complete brushfire of pure fire
- Finish – Very dry, long, cinnamon and cloves spice… for others numbing
- Water – Helped make it a bit more accessible
So what was the distinction? Well… those originally from India found it just too much alcohol and simply didn’t care for it at all… in short found it nearly undrinkable.
And those originally from outside India who have adopted India as home? Could go past the high alcohol strength to find interesting elements… in short found it drinkable. While perhaps not a 1st choice, certainly not a last one.
It was awkward to have such a peculiar palate divide and strange to have origins so firmly come into play.
However, our best discovery of the evening? The cask strength Aultmore goes brilliantly with our host’s home made banana bread! Just as we discovered those notes in the whisky, like magic – out came one of the best banana breads I’ve had in literally years!
Good baking and whisky – fabulous combination! And a great close to our sampling session.
What else did we taste in our Whisky Ladies “Worthy Whiskies” Sunday Sundowner?
- Mortlach NAS 49%
- Arran Amarone Cask Finish 50%
- Lochside (1981/2005) 43% G&MP)
- Aultmore 5 year (2007/2012) 66.8% (Master of Malt)
You can also find Whisky Lady in India on: