My last session with the Bombay Malt & Cigar gents was in January 2023. I dubbed it “Swan Song” as it celebrated a trio of whiskies all from distilleries that are either no more or so changed to be entirely different than the liquid we sampled.

I was back in April for their Irish evening with a Jameson quartet, but then have been out of India ever since. Naturally, the gents carried on with many interesting sessions – some of which had miniatures set aside for me to catch up with their tasting journey (lucky me!).

So what to do for the gents one year later? After the remarkable Chorlton Ardmore opened in Winnipeg, Canada, I decided to see if we could discover another gem. Rarely do I have a problem of plenty. However, in this case, I did!

It was a really tough call to select just the right ones… The latest Chorltons to make it to India included:

• Benrinnes 14 year 55% From May 2022, 10 years in a bourbon barrel then finished for 4 years in a sherry butt. Described as having a soft waxy fruitiness, then a classic sherry palate, shifting with water into tart fruits.
• Deanston 14 year 52.6% From the Apr 2023 releases, matured in a bourbon barrel, it was reputed to be young, zesty fruits, minerals, bready.
• Faemussach 21 year 56% From May 2022, Speculated to be from BenRiach. Described as very smoky, with quite mixed reviews. Clearly one for the peatheads!
• Glen Ord 8 year 57.9% From the July 2022 releases, matured in 1st fill Oloroso Hogshead, described as an old school sherry, jammy fruits, chewy.
• Glentauchers 14 year 61.6% (DE tasting) From the Apr 2023 releases, matured in a refilled sherry butt, it is described as having aromas of panettone and peaches, with the palate leaning towards chocolate brownies, elegant and cakey.
• Miltonduff 16 year 55.9% From July 2022, complex from boozy pineapple cake with a contrasting palate, talkative and changeable.
• Orkney 22 year 53.4% From February 2022, this Highland Park was more than decent but simply didn’t hold a candle to the Orkey 15 year released much earlier.
• Speyside 13 year 64.6% From the November 2021 releases, this whisky is well traveled. Brought from London to Paris to Germany, then on to India. It is reputed to be a peated single malt from an undisclosed distillery and casks (possibly Glenrothes). Described as having a smoldering nose, and an earthy oily peat.
• Teaninich 12 year 54.2% Also from May 2022, matured in a Hogshead, it is described as starting with forest elements, then becomes quite “yellow” and citrusy.
• Tuillabardine 29 year 47.5% From Summer 2022, opened in January 2022, it was an interesting dram with a contrasting interplay between aromas and palate. Not your typical first pick from the whisky cabinet though….

First, I removed from the mix the two open bottles – the Orkney and Tuillabardine.

Second, from the closed bottles, I eliminated the peatier drams – this simply wasn’t my mood or the right audience for peat. So that took the Speyside, Faemussach out of the equation.

Next, I considered future tasting sessions where I have another Glentauchers waiting to to compare with the 14-year. With this pair, I thought the Miltonduff would be a good companion. (Spoiler alert! The Glentauchers 8 year never made it to India – was opened instead in Germany and is spectacular!)

I rarely get to try anything from Teaninich or Benrinnes, so that alone put them into the top contenders spot. Particularly Teaninich has a not-so-stellar track record in my books. Would this be the bottle that tips the scales in a more positive direction? Similarly, I have had mixed experiences with Benrinnes – some quite appealing and others that simply didn’t work for me.

Deanston has its fans, yet has tended to strike me as quite ordinary or average, leaning towards the industrial in style – nothing hugely wrong but nothing very right either. However, my recent brush with the Deanston Chronicles edition prompted a desire to give further consideration. More promising, there was something about the Glen Ord that caught my fancy. Whilst not a massive Singleton fan, David’s description made this seem like it was quite a compelling dram and possibly the right way to finish the evening.

From this line of thinking a theme emerged! “Second Chances” – deliberately selecting whiskies from distilleries that are not familiar favorites. Re-approaching with an open mind, giving due consideration to the liquid in front of us.

Even better, as the Bombay Malt & Cigar gents evening was followed right away by the Whisky Ladies, I could check out how the drams compared from freshly being opened to just a day later, in a different setting, context, and participants.

Clearly, folks voted with their glasses – as this photo dramatically shows! Curious to know which is which? Read on over the next few days!

From right (#1) to left (#4), we ranked our whiskies by consumption as:

1. Glen Ord 8 year 57.9% By the end of both evenings and removing a small sample for Europe, there is barely a dram remaining! A full-bodied satisfying sherry dram!
2. Deanston 14 year 52.6% was the surprising runner-up. In fact, after this photo was taken, there was even less liquid?! Whilst it was still considered average, sometimes average works.
3. Benrinnes 14 year 55%. Remains a mixed experience. Some interesting elements but also disappointing on the palate after such an appealing nose. One described it as feeling a bit “cheated” by the taste after the teasing aromas!
4. Teaninich 12 year 54.2%. No converts to this distillery post our experience. Whilst I never say never, if even a Chorlton bottle doesn’t nudge me towards this distillery, it is safe to say that its profile simply isn’t one for me!

If you don’t want to miss a post, why not follow Whisky Lady on:

• WordPress https://whiskylady.co/
• FaceBook Whisky Lady India – https://www.facebook.com/WhiskyLadyIN 
• Twitter @WhiskyLadyIN