Contrast and compare – The Six Isles Standard vs Port

Early May in Nurnberg can be glorious – everything goes from grey to green, the sun often comes out, long days, warm but not sweltering. Whisky sipping is still possible, just veers more towards brighter, lighter styles away from heavy peats or dense sherries.

By a remarkable coincidence, a tasting companion brought a Six Isles Port expression to our evening, along with a 20 ml sample from an Advent Calendar. One sample alone was insufficient for a tasting… that was when I remembered I had the same Advent Calendar with another sample and also one from my Canada stash too! And this is how we had sufficient to try both the original and Port finish!

For those unfamiliar with this blend, The Six Isles celebrates Scottish island whiskies, embracing the maritime sensibility with light peat. The distilleries are fairly clear from most of the Islands via their descriptions:

  • Arran brings harmony with its Lochranza distillery
  • Jura distinctiveness – obviously Jura!
  • Mull is dramatic and colourful in its landscape and harbour – Tobermoray / Ledaig
  • Skye is a land of mountain ranges, rugged characterful – Talisker
  • Orkney in the far north with honey, wood smoke – Highland Park (likely not the Scapa)
  • Islay brings the wisp of peat smoke, with the distillery a mystery

This is a “pure” or “blended malt” with no grain whisky. Below is a picture of their old label for the standard expression…

The Six Isles 46%

  • Nose – Aromatic smoke, gentle, clear maritime stamp with the spray of sea salt – one taster even found a bit of Agave!
  • Palate – Whilst most enjoyable, it is a bit “light’ or superficial, missing a bit of depth
  • Finish – Short yet entirely pleasant

Overall, we pronounced it a good blend – the peat tobacco was light, keeping this more in the vein of a summer dram than one reserved for a cold winter day.

One tasting companion quipped, “It arrives like an Arran and leaves like an Islay“.

Six Isles Port Finish 48%

  • Nose – Similar vein as the standard, yet with more substance… a hint of port in the aromas, yet quite subtle… some fruit, a bit of vanilla
  • Palate – Caramelised bacon, very sweet and fruity – a bit citrusy with melons too, more pronounced tobacco as well
  • Finish – A nice cinnamon peat on the finish

We found this sharper with more depth than the standard expression. The extra 2% strength likely added to its character – everything had just a dash more “Ooomph!”

Here’s what they have to say about their Port finish:

  • Nose: Fragrant smoke, orange peel and cranberry, bonoffee tart and fresh dill
  • Palate: Red fruits and cream, a hint of vanilla, watermelon, grapefruit and soft peat smoke
  • Finish: Short, crisp and sweet with a mild lingering peat

After reading their tasting notes, I would tend to agree! Above all – what fun to compare these two expressions side by side!

PS – Both the Port expression and photos come courtesy of a Nurnberg International Whisky Explorers club!

If you don’t want to miss a post, why not follow Whisky Lady on:

Whisky Archives – Oban 14 year, Deanston 12 year, The Six Isles and Yellow Spot

Another from the archives… from June 2013 and my 1st whisky post on EverydayAsia. Hope you enjoy!

Tasting Notes from 20 June 2013

Following our standard format, we blind tasted before revealing the whisky. This month featured: Oban 14 year, Deanston 12 year, The Six Isles and Yellow Spot.

“Oh us fortunate few! What an evening it was!”

Oban 14 year – Golden amber colour. A light fruity sweet nose. Unexpectedly oily, chewy body with a spicy bite yet smooth. Short finish. Felt familiar, nice yet not exceptional.

Oban 14 year (photo: Carissa Hickling)

Deanston 12 year – A little ‘extra’ brought out by our host for those who missed trying it in an earlier meeting. Nuanced nose with over ripe fruit, sweet and spicy on the palate, lovely finish with a hint of spice that slowly dissipated. Delightful!

Deanston (Photo: Carissa Hickling)

The Six Isles – A vatted malt with single malts from the Scottish Islands: Islay, Jura, Mull, Arran, Skye and Orkney, this one kept us guessing! Quite peaty on the nose with hints of spice and other elements. Burnt ash, rich, oily on the palate yet with only a drop or two of water transformed into an exquisite smooth sweet whisky that would even pair well with desert. A lovely mellow finish. What a wonderful surprise!

The Six Isles (Photo: Carissa Hickling)

Yellow Spot 12 year – From Ireland, a single pot still Irish whisky produced for Mitchell & Son of Dublin, matured in bourbon, sherry and Malaga casks. The nose was fresh and sweet with hints of a complexity to come. On the palate, initially a blend of sea salt and honey, it rounded out with chocolate to fruit, supported by a woody robustness. The finish was particularly superb! Complex, with a gorgeous flavour that lingered…

It has garnered some very well deserved praise from Jim Murray (and us)! An exceptional whisky that hit all our favourite counts for a wonderful malt.

Yellow Spot (Photo: Carissa Hickling)

Any different opinions? Any recommendations along the lines of Yellow Spot?

You can also find Whisky Lady in India on: