Royal Lochnagar 12 year 40%

Our whisky host shared how they were touring other sites and practically stumbled upon Royal Lochanagar. They simply had to make a short detour for a distillery tour!

And why not? There is a royal precedent to touring this distillery! Neighbouring Balmoral Castle, Queen Victoria and Prince Albert were invited for a whisky tour in 1848. Post this experience, the Prince issued a royal warrant! Which was continued by King Edward VII and King George V.

Today, Royal Lochangar is the smallest whisky distillery in the Diageo stable, with a reputation for being a bit of a conundrum. Why? The two stills and worm tubs would tend to lend themselves to a ‘heavy’ style, but instead, great efforts are made to produce a ‘light’ new make spirit.

Bought on site for ~£50, the 12 year is part of their core range. What did we think?

Royal Lochnagar 12 year 40%

  • Nose – Incredibly sweet at first, a rich rumtopf full of soaked juicy fruits, lots of plums, cherries… then it shifted, revealing fresh grass with the heavy fruity aromas fading, instead we found a growing carmalized onion – almost like a sweet bacon jam, a bit sweet and salty, then oak, vanilla, marmalade with pronounced orange rind, even some apple cider vinegar or turpentine, and a shandy beer/sprite mix!
  • Finish – Woody, salty black licorice (a Nordic lakris style), some white pepper, a bit earthy, umami, sweet roasted vegetables, betel leaf, apples
  • Revisit – Astringent, dry

Many of our Whisky Ladies thought this expression might be much more interesting at 46% rather than 40%. It seemed a bit, well, too watered down.

Overall, we found it was a fairly easy-drinking dram. However, whilst it was relatively innocuous, there was nothing truly exceptional either.

Interestingly, they’ve kept many similar elements in their current official tasting notes vs those shared nearly a decade ago – right down to the turpentine!

  • Nose – A relatively closed nose. Planed wood, light toffee, boat varnish. Linseed oil behind, even putty, and later a lychee-like acidity. With water, the acidity comes up (acid drops), and the nose sweetens. Still a pleasant fresh woodiness or leatheriness, the varnish now supported by artists turpentine. Warm sand. After a while, coffee dregs with brown sugar. Not an obvious nose, however.
  • Body – Medium-bodied with a smooth mouthfeel.
  • Palate – This delicate malt offers fruits, planed wood, and light toffee. The palate is sweet before gaining in acidity.
  • Finish – Dry; medium-length, with an attractive lingering sandalwood aftertaste. Sharp and well-balanced.

Full disclosure, I had previously sampled this expression ~ 9 years earlier. We concluded it was a sharp varnish until it settled down and became more approachable. This time, I didn’t find the sandalwood aftertaste; the impression remained of something ordinary rather than extraordinary.

What else did we sample that evening?

If you don’t want to miss a post, why not follow Whisky Lady on:

Whisky Ladies Scottish Whisky Trail: Royal Lochnagar, Berry Bros + Rudd Sherry, Lum Reek

Patience is a virtue. And in this case, with our February 2026 Whisky Ladies session, it required 1.5 years of patience from both our host and her spouse! Each whisky was carefully selected from their Scottish Whisky trail. Then waited and waited and waited to be first opened for the ladies,  before our hosts could enjoy at their leisure!

We were introduced to the following:

From Royal warrant to an undisclosed single malt to a blend, it was a good reminder: never assume a previous experience will be the same in a different environment, a different decade, and a slightly different expression!

For many of us who find the heat of Mumbai and peat incompatible, it could simply be the style of peat one is trying! This MacNair blend converted more than a few to peat!

What is wonderful about tasting in a diverse group is that we have a range of reactions to the whiskies sampled. This particular evening was surprisingly unanimous and quite clear in our ranking: Lum Reek was the winner by far! Followed by Royal Lochnagar with Berry Bros & Rudd’s Sherry Cask lagging in last place…

As to why this was the case? You will simply need to click on the whisky links to read detailed tasting notes!

If you don’t want to miss a post, why not follow Whisky Lady on:

Royal Lochnagar 12 year 40%

After the original Rampur 43%, we were primed for something different… We sampled blind from a freshly opened bottle, having no clue what we were sipping.

Royal Lochnagar 12 year 40%

  • Nose – Varnish, oily, sweet, a bit like a saag sabzi (spinach veggie dish), bitter, old fruits, cold pressed coconut oil, a little lemon zest, some light liquorice, sense of being heavy
  • Palate – Sharp, hot, spice, then as we grew accustomed to it, appreciated its chewy quality with a good mouthfeel, one even mentioned ‘oil cake’, very smooth but fairly standard in character
  • Finish – Green pepper oil, bitter
  • Water – The oiliness comes on more sweetly. Some shared with water, it simply joined the territory of “Just a good a drinkable whisky”

As we sipped and discussed, we appreciated how it retains its aromas, a nice pleasant finish with many enjoying the finish more than the initial taste on the palate, but in all not a terribly complex whisky. As for age, it was hard to judge but seemed in the NAS category. In short, we found it a decent dram, enjoyable in its way but somehow quite ordinary.

With the reveal some surprise – none would have thought the whisky had matured for 12 years.

Royal Lochnagar is located near Balmoral Castle and has been producing whisky since 1845. Once upon a time, you would not find an official bottling easily however with Diageo’s “Classic Malts Selection“, it joins the ranks of travel retail popping up all over the globe.

It is described as “a fragrant Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky with a delightful balance of fruit and spices.” with official tasting notes of:

  • Nose – Planed wood, light toffee, boat varnish. After a while, coffee with brown sugar. A relatively closed nose. Linseed oil behind, even putty, and later a lychee-like acidity. With water the acidity comes up (acid drops), and the nose sweetens. Still a pleasant fresh woodiness or leatheriness, the varnish now supported by artists turpentine. Warm sand. After a while, coffee dregs with brown sugar. Not an obvious nose, however.
  • Taste – Pleasant; an initial sweetness is quickly overtaken by acidity. 
  • Finish – Dry; medium-length, with an attractive lingering sandalwood aftertaste.

Hmm… at least they haven’t over-inflated various elements and admit to the varnish, acidity, and yes – sandalwood isn’t a bad way of describing the finish.

But overall… nothing to prompt rushing out to explore more from this distillery. Simply one to enjoy for what it is.

Also from our evening:

You can also find Whisky Lady in India on: