Johnnie Walker Blue Label

With Diwali just behind us, we came together for a different celebration! The Whisky Ladies November 2025 session just happened to bring together a recognition of a Presidential award, a marriage, and a birthday – what fun!

This theme of celebration was reflected in the whiskies as well:

Johnie Walker Blue Label Xordinaire Cognac Cask 40% ~GBP 200
Auchentoshan American Oak 40% ~Eur 27 (1L)
Laphroaig “The Cask Legacy” 48% (Laphroaig Cask Collection) ~Eur 122

All can be found in travel retail, and reflect quite different styles.

I think the last time I gave proper attention to Johnnie Walker was at a large music festival at Mehboob Studios in Bandra, Mumbai. They had a full set of options on offer, and whilst I took no notes, I was left with a solid reminder of why these blends are so universally popular.

Like many things, we often overlook the “ordinary” in pursuit of the “extraordinary”… so what did we think of their special XO cognac finished cask “Xordinaire”?

Johnie Walker Blue Label Xordinaire 40%

Nose – It greeted us with stewed peaches, pears, lots of crisp green apples, then some guava, and honey. As it opened up more, it shifted from fresh fruits to stewed fruits – particularly apples, and from honey to a darker treacle. Behind all of this, after the first sip, was a hint of marmite, leather, plus peppercorns…
Palate – It began quite fruity, then black peppercorns took centre stage. Overall, it was quite “thin” on the palate. On the 2nd sip, it became a bit nutty, bitter, and woody. One even found beetroot!
Finish – There, yet quite short
Ice – I know we typically eschew ice with whisky; however, the instinct to add was spot on! It brightened the whisky on the nose, brought out a pleasant caramel sweetness on the palate, and even a hint of cream.

Whilst it wasn’t “extraordinairy”, it was not bad at all. That said, we couldn’t discern much Cognac cask influence and were frankly shocked at the price tag! Surely it couldn’t actually be retailing in travel retail for Eur 230 / SGD 340 / AED 960 / INR 24,000??

Touted as the perfect whisky for non-whisky drinkers, I can certainly think of more affordable options for a neophyte consumer.

We moved on to another travel retail bottle – this time from Lowland distillery Auchentoshan.

Auchentoshan American Oak 40%

Nose – Delightful! Sweet candy, lemon, mosambi, bananas, heather, then began to shift into tobacco leaf, lots of vanilla, some date, clove, black pepper, and even a bit of date, chalk, with a faintly metallic element
Palate – Soft, very smooth, sweet yet also with a prick of spice, fruit, and coconut cream
Finish – Chilli, lemon rind, and a hint of almond – more specifically a Kashmiri mamra

While there was no need to add water, we set the glass aside and returned to find a creamy perfume, something almost reminiscent of Tutti Fruitti ice cream! Talk turned from desserts to food, and, like often happens with a companionable dram, merriment took over from the malt. In our books – that is a good thing indeed!

What does Auchentoshan have to say?

To the eye: Look for the vivid, bright gold colour when selecting your Auchentoshan American Oak. Wondering what gives whisky its colour? The delicate maturing process. As the single malt matures in the quality bourbon barrels, a new and complex colour and flavour profile is created over time.
To the nose: A vibrant bourbon infused vanilla and coconut with layers of zesty citrus fruit, making this Scotch Single Malt from Auchentoshan stand out from the crowd.
To the tongue: A refreshingly smooth whisky taste. Lively, with vanilla cream, coconut and white peach.
To the end: Crisp, with sugared grapefruit and a lingering hint of spice.

Overall, this one hit the spot for many of our ladies. And for the price-point? At around 1/10th the cost of the Johnnie Walker, the Auchentoshan would make a much better introduction to whisky for someone new to the spirit!

We then radially switched gears from a light, sprightly, easy-going Lowland style to Islay – and that too the peat beast Laphroaig! I admit upfront that it has been some time since I had a Laphroaig whisky. Their signature ashy style simply isn’t my preferred peat, so I’ve tended to skip over most opportunities to explore this distillery. Which is exactly why I welcome opportunities like this evening – to put my preconceived notions to the test!

Laphroaig “The Cask Legacy” 48% (Laphroaig Cask Collection)

Nose – Peaty! With that delicious bacon jam we often seek out! There was cedar wood, salty butter, ash yet citrus too, faint mulberry jam, even some custard apple? Some ripe figs, nutmeg… after the 1st sip we also found raisins, cinnamon, finding it became milder and mellower the longer it was in the glass
Palate – A proper Laphroaig. Ash. Yet also joined by jackfruit, apples, smooth yet oily.
Finish – Buttery, with peat, tobacco, a bit nutty – long and lasting

Like the other glasses, we set this aside to revisit and found it was indeed ashy, yet it was also quite nice, well-rounded, and overall rewarding.

Here’s what Laphraoig shares with their official tasting notes:

Colour: Deep, warming sunset orange.
Nose: Whiffs of our signature peat smoke with burnt apricot and raisins. 
Palate: Broad and soft oak, rich caramelised dark fruit and a lively dried fruitiness.
Finish: Lingering nuts, peat and oiled wood.
Maturation: Aged in first-fill Bourbon barrels then new European oak hogsheads.

It was almost like this Legacy expression was taunting: “So you thought to dismiss us? Think again! People love us for a very good reason!” I felt properly “schooled” and really enjoyed this one.