A funny thing is starting to happen… as our original whisky tasting group looks forward to our 5th year together, we are beginning to do a little inadvertent duplication.
As our practice is to rotate hosts with each host responsible for curating the evening, not disclosing the whiskies procured for our sampling pleasure until after we have tasted blind, it means we do not coordinate with each other to ensure we aren’t buying the same or similar thing.
At the time of the reveal, we are now occasionally hearing ‘Oh’ in a different tone as the whisky just tried was already acquired for a forthcoming session by another member. That happened in August with the Bruichladdich The Organic Scottish Barley 50%.
However for those that are similar, rather than exactly the same, it means we can play around with interesting comparisons… and in the coming months we will have opportunities to do just that!
For example, November’s three whiskies included:
- Hibiki Harmony NAS 43% – Technically well-crafted… but where is the soul?
- Aultmore ‘Foggie Moss’ 18 year 46% – Surprisingly exceedingly ‘nice’!
- Glenburgie 15 year 43% (Gordon & MacPhail) – Pronounced the “Downton Abbey” of whiskies!
Why is that remarkable?
We had just sampled the Aultmore 15 year bottled by Gordon & MacPhail the previous month… and here was another Aultmore. Naturally we have asked the hosts from both sessions to bring along both bottles to our next tasting in January!
And now that I have the delightful Whisky Ladies group too, that provides scope for even more such comparisons! Between the two whisky tasting groups, I was able to put side-by-side the distillery release of Caol Ila 12 year next to a Gordon & MacPhail Caol Ila 12 year.
For those of you part of a whisky tasting group, how do you acquire whiskies and organise your sessions?
And do you sometimes get that ‘Oh!’ of duplication or ‘Oooh!’ for another opportunity to do a different kind of comparison?
- 10 tips for whisky hosting
- Three tips for whisky tasting order
- Caol Ila 12 year vs Caol Ila 12 year (G&MP)
You can also find Whisky Lady in India on: